top of page

Oroville Man Sentenced to Four Years in State Prison for Arson at Historic Lott Home

8 minutes ago
3 min read

11/18/2026 "Press Release" - Butte County District Attorney's Office 



Brandon Cody Dingman, 37, of Oroville, was sentenced today in Butte County Superior Court to four years in state prison for intentionally setting a fire inside Oroville’s historic Lott Home.


The sentence followed Dingman’s October 21, 2026, no-contest plea to felony arson of a structure. The offense carried a sentencing range of two, four, or six years in state prison.


At today’s hearing, the Butte County District Attorney’s Office asked the judge to impose the upper term of six years. Prosecutors emphasized that Dingman broke a window and threw burning clothing onto an antique chair inside the home, with the stated intention of setting the structure on fire. They argued that his actions endangered both the historic building and the surrounding residential neighborhood, noting that even Dingman acknowledged that a larger fire could spread beyond the property.


Dingman’s public defender, Larry Pilgrim, asked the judge to place Dingman on probation and send him to intensive drug court treatment. Judge Michael Deems denied the request, finding that the seriousness of the offense did not justify a sentence less than prison. After considering the circumstances of the crime and Dingman’s background, Judge Deems imposed the middle term of four years, citing Dingman’s limited criminal history.


Butte County District Attorney Mike Ramsey said the case began at approximately 2:36 a.m. on October 9, 2026, when Oroville police officers were dispatched to the Lott Home on Montgomery Street after the building’s motion and fire alarms were triggered. An officer arrived within minutes and found a broken window near the home’s southeast corner. Fresh blood, broken glass, and the odor of smoke were present near the window.


Fire personnel entered the building and confirmed that the fire was no longer actively burning. Inside, investigators found an antique wooden chair with burned and charred upholstery, along with ash and debris around it. Investigators later observed a burn mark on the floor beneath the chair.


Officers located Dingman nearby, with fresh lacerations on his right arm. Dingman admitted that he had broken the window and started the fire inside the building. He told officers that he broke the window with his hand, used a torch-style lighter to ignite a pair of shorts, and placed the burning clothing through the opening and onto a chair inside the Lott Home.


Dingman told officers that he had a methamphetamine addiction and that “voices” told him he had “won” the Lott Home as his own. When he found the door to the home locked, he became angry and attempted to burn the home down.


Judge Deems also ordered Dingman to pay $238 in restitution to the City of Oroville for the broken window's replacement and reserved jurisdiction to modify the award or order additional restitution if the City identifies further repair costs, replacement expenses, or other qualifying losses resulting from the arson.


Built in 1856 by Charles Fayette Lott, a California Gold Rush pioneer who served as a lawyer, judge, and state senator, the Lott Home remains an important part of Oroville’s historic heritage.


“Setting a fire in a residential neighborhood puts lives and the entire community at risk,” Ramsey said. “Our foremost responsibility is to protect the public from conduct that can quickly turn deadly and cause widespread devastation. This prison sentence holds Mr. Dingman accountable for deliberately creating that danger and makes clear that conduct threatening our community’s safety and history will be treated seriously.”

Dingman has remained in custody since his arrest on October 9, 2026.




 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page